A Bible lesson on freedom, choice, suffering, God’s grief, redemption, and eternal life
Patrick Henry declared:
“Give me liberty, or give me death!”
Those words have lived for generations because we understand what he meant.
Freedom is precious.
How many men and women have died on battlefields defending freedom? How many families have lost fathers, mothers, sons, and daughters because someone believed freedom was worth defending—even at the cost of life itself?
But what is this freedom we value so highly? Freedom from what? Freedom for what?
At its foundation is something God gave mankind from the beginning:
The freedom to choose.
Free will.
We want to think for ourselves. We want to speak for ourselves. We want to decide what we believe, whom we love, what we will do, and whom we will serve.
And then mankind turns around and asks:
“If there is a loving God, why is there so much pain and suffering in the world?”
That is a serious question. But perhaps we have been looking at only one side of it.
We know about our suffering.
What we seldom stop to consider is God’s suffering.
And perhaps we cannot understand the cost of freedom until we consider both.
Read: Deuteronomy 30:19–20; Joshua 24:15
God said: “I have set before you life and death, blessing and cursing; therefore choose life.”
Joshua said: “Choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve.”
Notice what God does.
He gives instruction.
He tells us the consequences.
And then He tells us to choose.
Suppose God had created human beings who were incapable of refusing Him.
They could obey every command.
They could sing praises.
They could bow before Him.
They could say, “I love You.”
But if they had no ability to do otherwise, what would those words mean?
Where would willing obedience be? Where would love be?
A machine can perform exactly as it was programmed. But it cannot decide to love its creator.
God created something different.
He created beings
capable of hearing Him—and refusing Him.
Capable of loving Him—and rejecting Him.
Capable of obedience—and rebellion.
That makes possible something enormously valuable:
A creation that can willingly choose its Creator.
But the moment genuine choice exists, something else becomes possible.
The wrong choice.
That is the price attached to freedom.
Think about Patrick Henry's statement again:
“Give me liberty, or give me death.”
The statement has meaning because there were alternatives.
Liberty was possible.
Death was possible.
A choice existed.
Suppose there were no such thing as liberty. Then demanding liberty would be meaningless.
Choice requires alternatives. We sometimes say we want free will—but then object because the world contains circumstances in which wrong choices can be made and painful consequences can follow.
But what would free will mean in a world where every undesirable possibility had been removed?
If I can choose only the right thing, I haven't really chosen it.
If I can say yes but cannot say no, what does yes mean?
If I can obey but cannot disobey, what is obedience?
And if I can say, “God, I love You,” but I have no possibility of rejecting Him, what does that declaration mean?
God placed mankind in a world where choices are real. And real choices have real consequences.
Read: Genesis 2:16–17; Genesis 3:1–6
God gave Adam and Eve instruction. The serpent challenged that instruction. The fruit looked desirable.
And mankind chose.... POORLY
God's willingness to permit the choice did not make the wrong choice right.
That distinction is important.
God allowing us to make a decision is not the same thing as God approving our decision.
We see that throughout life. Every day we are becoming something through the choices we make.
Tell the truth today.
Tell the truth tomorrow.
Tell the truth when telling the truth costs something.
Eventually truthfulness becomes part of your character.
The same principle operates in the other direction.
Lie today.
Lie tomorrow.
Lie when lying is convenient.
Eventually deception becomes part of your character.
Practice mercy and you become different from the person who continually practices revenge.
Practice humility and you become different from the person controlled by pride.
Listen to God and obey Him, and you become different from the person who continually refuses Him.
In that sense, our choices help shape who we become.
God has given us His Word.
He has told us what leads toward life.
He has warned us what leads toward death.
And then He allows us to choose.
Read: Romans 3:23; Romans 6:16–23; Galatians 6:7–8
We want freedom for ourselves. But there is something we sometimes forget:
Everyone else has it too.
Another person's freedom can hurt me.
My freedom can hurt another person.
A man can choose to lie.... Someone else suffers.... A person can choose violence.... Someone else is injured.
A husband or wife can choose betrayal.
A family is shattered.
A parent can choose anger.
A child carries the scars.
A person can choose greed.
Someone else may lose what he needs.
So when someone asks:
“Why does God allow people to hurt one another?”
we should at least recognize what we are asking.
We want God to give us freedom while preventing other people from exercising that freedom whenever their choices might hurt us.
But if God intervened before every wrong decision—if He prevented every lie before it could be spoken, every betrayal before it could occur, every hateful word before it could leave someone's mouth—how much freedom would remain?
Freedom is dangerous. And Scripture never pretends otherwise.
Paul tells us that we can even use freedom in such a way that we become slaves to the very things we chose.
A man may say:
“Nobody tells me what to do.”
Yet anger controls him.
Pride controls him.
Lust controls him.
Bitterness controls him.
Addiction controls him.
He demanded freedom and used it to build his own prison.
That is part of the terrible cost of choice.
Read: Job 1:20–22; John 9:1–3; James 1:2–4; Romans 12:15
But human wrongdoing does not explain everything.
What about the tornado?
The earthquake?
The flood?
Disease?
The unexpected death of someone we love?
What about the child who dies?
We may not know why a particular tragedy occurred.
And we should not pretend that we know something God has not told us.
Jesus' disciples once saw a man who had been blind from birth and immediately wanted to know whose sin caused it.
Jesus rejected their assumption... So we must be careful.
But there is another part of the question we can answer.
Even circumstances we did not choose present us with choices.
A tornado strikes.
Now choices appear everywhere.
Will I help my neighbor?
Will I share what I have?
Will I take advantage of someone else's misery?
Will I comfort?
Will I serve?
Will I sacrifice?
Will I pray?
Will I trust God even when I do not understand?
Someone we love dies.
We did not choose the loss.
But eventually choices confront us.
Will grief turn us toward God or permanently away from Him?
Will we allow others to help us?
Will we someday use what we have experienced to comfort another grieving person?
None of that makes the tragedy pleasant.
None of it means the suffering person should not cry.
Job grieved.
Jesus wept.
Scripture tells us:
“Weep with those who weep.”
Faith in the middle of suffering does not always stand tall and fearless.
Sometimes faith is on its knees.
Sometimes it is crying.
Sometimes it is saying:
“God, I don't understand.”
But it can still be faith.
Life gives us many different opportunities to choose.
Not merely choices about whether we will lie, steal, forgive, or become angry.
We also make choices in the storms.
Choices in disappointment.
Choices in loss.
Choices when life is unfair.
Choices when there seems to be no answer.
Those choices also help determine what we become.
And therefore the price of meaningful freedom is very high.
Read: Genesis 6:5–6; Luke 19:41–44; Matthew 23:37; Ephesians 4:30
This may be the part we have overlooked...We know mankind suffers... We talk about our suffering constantly.
But what does our freedom cost God?
Genesis tells us that when God saw the wickedness of mankind:
“He was grieved in His heart.”
Think about that.
God created mankind.
He gave us life.
He gave us a world in which to live.
He gave instruction.
He gave us the ability to choose.
And then His own creation used that freedom to rebel against Him.
People use the minds He gave them to deny Him.
They use the mouths He gave them to curse Him.
They use the strength He gave them to hurt one another.
They mock Him.
They ridicule Him.
They shake their fists toward heaven.
And God permits creatures He created to reject their Creator.
Why?
Because the same freedom that permits a man to shake his fist at God permits another man to fall on his knees and say:
“My Lord and my God.”
Look at Jesus approaching Jerusalem.
He weeps