Our purpose in the Gold Cord Fellowship is to encourage people to trust God, hear His Word, and live by it. That begins with allowing Scripture to establish what we believe and how we respond.
Some people express themselves freely. Others are quiet. A person may cry while reading Scripture; another may read the same passage, consider it carefully, and quietly change how he lives.
We must be careful about making our own manner of responding a requirement for someone else. If we teach people to measure their faith by the intensity of their feelings, what happens when those feelings fade? What happens to the person who has never been outwardly emotional?
Some people are told that unless they experienced an overwhelming emotional moment when they were saved, their salvation must be doubtful. We should examine that teaching by asking: Where does Scripture make such an experience a requirement?
We have reason to rejoice in salvation. But the foundation of our confidence is what God has said. An emotional display cannot substitute for faith and obedience, and a quiet disposition does not establish that someone lacks them.
Likewise, being raised with Christian teaching does not remove our responsibility to examine ourselves. Each of us must hear God’s Word and respond to it.
Luke begins his Gospel by explaining that the account rests on testimony delivered by eyewitnesses. He writes so that his reader may know the certainty of the things he has been taught (Luke 1:1–4).
John explains that the signs he recorded were written so that readers might believe Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and have life in His name (John 20:30–31).
These writers invite us to consider testimony about things that happened. Their accounts give us something to read, examine, and understand.
But someone may ask, “What about the differences between the Gospel accounts? Can I trust them?”
That is a fair question, and it deserves careful attention.
Why Witnesses Give Different Accounts
In Cold-Case Christianity, homicide detective J. Warner Wallace discusses why witnesses to the same event do not necessarily give identical accounts.
Their positions, attention, and experience affect which details they notice and report. One person includes something another leaves out. One concentrates on a person’s words, while another describes an action.
Such differences need examination, but they do not automatically make the witnesses unreliable. Wallace observes that natural variations can also weigh against the suggestion that witnesses rehearsed a single story together.
Differences alone do not prove accuracy or rule out collusion. They do, however, give us reason to avoid demanding identical wording before we will consider accounts trustworthy.
We must distinguish between accounts that contribute different details and accounts that make genuinely incompatible claims.
One Blind Man or Two
Matthew describes two blind men calling out to Jesus near Jericho. Mark tells us about Bartimaeus, a blind man who called out to Him (Matthew 20:29–34; Mark 10:46–52).
Does mentioning one man contradict mentioning two?
Suppose I tell you that I spoke with Tim this morning. Later, I tell someone else that I spoke with Tim and Richard. Both statements can be true. The first statement did not say I spoke with Tim alone.
Likewise, Mark names Bartimaeus without saying he was the only blind man present. Matthew includes two men. The difference in the number mentioned does not, by itself, establish a contradiction.
Notice how easily we could create a problem by adding one word: “only.”
Mark did not write that word. If I supply it and then object to what the passage says, I am arguing with my own addition.
That example does not answer every difficult question in Scripture. It does show why we should read carefully before deciding that two accounts cannot agree.
We can approach Scripture with expectations about what it ought to say. We may bring a familiar teaching, a personal preference, or a powerful feeling. Unless we are careful, we begin supplying words and conclusions that the passage itself does not contain.
An emotional requirement can become another such addition. We take our own experience and make it the experience everyone else must have. Then a quiet person begins to question his faith because he does not respond as we do.
Our responsibility is to distinguish what God has communicated from what we have brought to the reading.
What does the passage actually say? What is the surrounding discussion? What do the other accounts contribute? Am I allowing Scripture to correct my understanding?
God’s warning against adding to or taking away from His commands should make us careful with His words (Deuteronomy 4:2). We should neither supply a requirement He has not given nor dismiss one He has given.
The Bereans received the teaching willingly and searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether it was true (Acts 17:11). Their willingness to believe went together with careful examination.
That is a sound place for us to stand.
Coming with the humility of a child means being willing to learn, receive correction, and trust. Jesus calls us to humility in Matthew 18:3–4. Such humility belongs alongside the careful examination we see in the Bereans.
We do not have to manufacture a feeling before we can take God seriously. We can read, examine, learn, and respond.
When we encounter a difficulty, we can acknowledge it honestly and continue studying without inventing an answer. We should distinguish a possible explanation from something Scripture expressly tells us.
Our aim is to understand what God has communicated. My opinion must remain open to correction by His Word, just as yours must.
When we understand a command, we can obey it.
Jesus described the wise man as the person who hears His sayings and does them. He compared that person to a man who built his house on rock. The foolish man heard but did not put those sayings into practice (Matthew 7:24–27).
That brings faith into daily life: our choices, our conduct, our treatment of others, and our willingness to be corrected.
Jesus also connects love for Him with keeping His commandments (John 14:15). That gives love an expression we can practice, whether our outward manner is quiet or expressive.
What has God said that I already understand?
Am I adding a requirement because it matches my experience or preference?
Am I setting aside a command because obeying it would require me to change?
What step can I take today to live by His Word?
Our personalities differ. Our feelings change. God’s Word gives us something dependable to return to.
Hear Him. Believe Him. Put His teaching into practice.
J. Warner Wallace, Cold-Case Christianity: A Homicide Detective Investigates the Claims of the Gospels. See the discussion headed “So, Why Can’t They Agree?” Page numbers vary by edition.
Scripture passages for personal study: Deuteronomy 4:2; Matthew 7:24–27; Matthew 18:3–4; Matthew 20:29–34; Mark 10:46–52; Luke 1:1–4; John 14:15; John 20:30–31; Acts 17:11.